There has been considerable traffic to an earlier post over the unfolding crisis in Ukraine. [update in progress, 5th March 2014].
Originally posted on Leaders We Deserve:
The question assumes the two categories are ‘either-or’. A better question: are Vlidimir Putin’s behaviours explained better by transformational or charismatic leadership maps? Beware the ‘Either-or’ question
Beware the ‘Either-or’ question
A quick visit to textbooks of leadership (such as Dilemmas of Leadership) provides ways of answering the questions and explains the difficulties inherent in an ‘either-or’ formulation.
The charismatic leadership map
Charismatic leaders have been mapped from ancient times. The core assumption about them is that they have special skills or gifts so that followers are captivated by them and their ideas.
The transformational leadership map
The transformational map is a modern treatment of leaders (ca 1980s) which acknowledges some features are charismatic. The Transformation leader, as its label implies, transforms the worlds of their followers (which can be local to a team or organization, or global to the leader of a Nation State).
Transformational leaders are assessed most commonly on a scale…
View original post 405 more words