Will Osama bin Laden be more influential after his death?

In earlier days, miliary leaders were rarely deliberately killed, even in battle. Other political and military advantages were weighed against such actions. A charismatic leader may have more influence dead than alive. It is not a matter of simple binary logic of ‘wanted dead or alive’

by Tudor Rickards

These gloomy thoughts occured to me on learning of the death of Osama ben Ladin by American forces in Pakistan last night [May 1st 2011]. I wondered about the ‘dead or alive’ dilemma as posed by some commentators.

Not simple binary logic

Like most dilemmas, it is not just a matter of simple binary logic. Once bin Laden’s location had been established, there were several options that had to be considered. Not all would have resulted in his death. If he had escaped an attack there would have been strengthening of his symbolic signficance to many unfavourable to Western overseas interventions however justified they might appear in the West. Or if he had been captured unharmed, there would be an extended process of establishing legal charges, and carrying out a sentence (I am presuming the process would have established charges of terrorism and mass murder against him). Such a process would have be long drawn-out, and likely to induce responses not all of which can be anticipated.

Bin Laden’s three assets

My point is this. Bin Laden possessed three powerful assets in pursuing his aims. He was enormously wealthy and he was able to present himself as a leader commanding loyalty to his cause and to himself. Great wealth can add to the social cachet of any individual. It can transform a nerd into a idealized business leader. It can reinforce self-belief into ego-mania. When the wealth is linked to a cause, the symbolic effect is heightened. And finally, if the individual fits the stereotype of a charismatic leader, bingo. He had the potential to become a revolutionary and charismatic leader. Such men are dangreous. But their violent removal is also beset with dangers.

Charisma

Shakespeare wrote how the evil that a man does lives after him, the good is oft interred with his bones. But Shakespearewas speaking ironically. It could also be argued that for followers, the charisma a man establishes lives after him. It is the wrongs which are oft interred with his bones.

To go more deeply

President Obama’s announcement (video)

3 Responses to Will Osama bin Laden be more influential after his death?

  1. Tudor says:

    In the haste to capture immediate reactions to the death of OBL, I regretably did not cover even briefly the back-story of his upbringing, the founding and significance of Al Qaida, the Twin Towers attacks,their impact on US forign policy under President Bush and so on.

  2. OBL established AL Qaida which attacked the twin towers in USA , the question is “was he really influential during his life ? ” then is charismatic leadership in the past practiced the way these days ?, i mean if we considered OBL as a charismatic leader then for who ,none of AL Qaida members symbolized him during his life as known to be i.e. Hitler and his follower ? i think the american media had a great contribution to symbolize him as a leader .

    lets remember that OBL had established a paradigm not a normal movement and the Americans will be in a deep dilemma if they don’t symbolize him , why ? if the Americans are fighting “a way of thinking” then what is the winning indicator, putting him as a charismatic leader , target him and kill him will make it easy

    i think the Americans have lost the battle because OBL way of thinking successfully got into his follows while the Americans focused on him as leader deviating from the real battle in the way of thinking

    if the Americans will keep treating their battle with terrorism this way the guy will stay in peoples’ minds and got more followers but if switched the battle field into peoples minds then he will be forgotten easily

  3. Tudor says:

    You make a serious point there. Thank you Samer. And best wishes.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: